Border Collie Temperament: The Workaholic of all breeds

Are you ready to learn more about the most trainable breed of them all and find out if this dog breed is the right choice for you? Then you've come to the right Border Collie temperament blog post.

Border Collies are intelligent dogs with unyielding energy levels. Their penetrating expressions and attentive demeanour make for an active and highly trainable dog and a handful for a novice dog owner.

Whether you're a novice dog owner or have owned dogs before, it's always good to learn more about the temperament of the dog you'd like to bring into your home. Border Collies are real eye-catchers with stunning coats and bright eyes. Whilst some dogs love to sleep and relax, this dog's favourite passing time is training for obedience and agility competitions or solving complex mind-boggling tasks.

In the following blog, we will look at the Border Collies' impressive history as herding dogs, their temperament and whether this dog is everything you wished for in a good family dog. So, without delay, let's explore this bundle of energy in more detail.

Border Collie History

Border Collie Temperament
Border Collies are one of the most loyal breeds on the planet

The Border Collies' history starts in Northumberland on the borders between Scotland and England. The Scots had herding and sheepdogs for centuries before establishing this dog breed. It is estimated that the first herding dogs who worked alongside farmers were around the first century BC.

The word Collie originates from the Celtic term "useful". On the other hand, the Scottish Highlands are home to the Colley Sheep, which has characteristic black markings. These could refer to the black markings on the Border Collie as well.

When the Romans invaded the British Isles, they brought with them dogs who were able to control and move livestock. These roman breeds paved the way for many dog breeds. When the Vikings invaded England, they brought over Spitz-type dogs. This opened the way for the breeding of other dog breeds. One of them showed special excelling abilities in herding and athleticism.

In 1893, one dog was born who paved the way for the first Border Collies: Old Hemp.

Appearances were not the central aspect when breeding dogs back then. Instead, having the right abilities to carry out work in the field was crucial. And this is where Old Hemp comes into play.

Old Hemp's ability and natural instincts for herding livestock were so outstanding that he quickly became the top working dog on the farm. However, the most staggering discovery was that Old Hemp didn't rely on his bark to usher livestock, unlike other sheepdogs. He instead used body positions and eyes and anticipated the sheep's movements while adapting to them.

Old Hemp's outstanding abilities quickly made the round, and his owner, Adam Telfer, let him be the sire to many other puppies. As a result, old Hemp's descendants could bag many farmers' championships and prices for their natural herding instincts in the following years. In fact, many Border Collies of today can be traced back to Old Hemp's lineage.

The International Sheep Dog Society, founded in 1906, wished to distinguish between all the different Collie breeds: Smooth Collie, Rough Collie, and Scotch Collie were typical references to Collies in the 1800s. However, the first reference to the Border Collie can be found in 1915.

Wiston Cap, a tri-colour Collie born in 1963, was another vital sire for the Border Collie breed. Unfortunately, because Border Collies were mainly bred for their natural instincts and herding abilities, health issues were often considered second. This is where some hereditary diseases were introduced into these dogs, which will be mentioned below.

But some sires contributed to the breed with their kind nature. These traits are also embedded into the Border Collie, unlike the first Collies, who were a little averse to strangers.

Their kind nature is why Border Collies are increasingly considered excellent family dogs.

The UK Kennel Club recognised the Border Collie in 1976. However, the American Kennel Club only followed in 1995.

In Q2 2022, 550 Border Collies have been registered with the UK Kennel Club, which matches the average amount registered in prior years. It shows the ongoing love story of the people in England and this beautiful dog breed.

Q1 2021

Q2 2021

Q3 2021

Q4 2021

Yearly 2021

Q1 2022

Q2 2022








Source: UK Kennel Club October 2022

Now that we have a rough idea about their breeding history, let's dive into how your life with a Border Collie might look.

What is a Border Collie's Temperament like?

Border Collie Temperament
A black and white Border Collie is probably the most common one

It's certainly never dull! The Border Collie is a working dog supreme with a drive to work like no other dog. Their working ethics are solid and come instinctively. Hence, even today, Border Collies are superior in sheepherding.

The Border Collies' energy level should not be underestimated. They're one of the most complex dog breeds that you can encounter. 1 hour around the block won't cut it for this breed.

The main reason Border Collies are given away is because their exercise levels can't be met by the average family.

If you decide to not work your Border Collie and are looking for a family dog, keep in mind this dog needs hours of mental and physical stimulation. So please only get one of these dogs if you have time to dedicate to them. The Border Collie is one of the most active dog breeds and is almost considered to have a different level of energy.

Border Collie Temperament
Border Collies need mental and physical stimulation to thrive

If you enjoy canine sports like agility, flyball and obedience training, the Border Collie is a perfect choice.

Overall, if you're an active person who goes hiking, climbing and biking regularly, the Border Collie is your ideal companion dog. They will never let you down. But, unfortunately, you're more likely to struggle to keep up with this medium-sized dog.

Centuries of herding made the Border Collie a confident dog who can make its own decisions if necessary. However, they have an independent streak if their human isn't providing guidance.

Training can become arduous if the Border Collie doesn't sense any clear direction. Don't be fooled by their cute looks: The Border Collie is a true mastermind, and they're strong-willed. They require consistent, calm and strong leadership. This dog will sense uneasiness and timidness rather quickly, and you won't do them or yourself a service by choosing them as your dog.

Border Collie Temperament
This velcro dog stucks with you everywhere

A bored Border Collie is very often a recipe for disaster. They can become nervous and destructive if they have nothing to do.

Rather than asking yourself if this dog is for you, you should ask yourself if you're the right person for this dog. If you don't give them a job, they will take it upon themselves to find a job: That might not be what you had in mind!

The Border Collie will require your guidance, presence and perseverance. They're not easy dogs to handle, and we wouldn't recommend them for novice dog owners who aren't home all the time. Without firm guidance and leadership, this dog will try to outsmart you at every corner. They will very likely succeed and can quickly become mentally tiring for you.

If you do, however, provide guidance and consistent leadership, this dog will be a joy to train. They learn incredibly quickly, are goal-orientated, and are the most intelligent dog breed. The Border Collie is undoubtedly here to solve your problems with you. The partnership between you and your Border Collie is incredibly unique. Not many dogs form such a close relationship with their owner on such a high level.

Border Collies can have the tendency to herd. If you don't own sheep, their instinct can take over, and they can start herding children, bikes, cars or other pets. This includes staring the herding object down, chasing or even nipping. You must learn to re-direct this behaviour as early as possible and direct this instinct into other tasks like agility and obedience.

The Border Collie stare can be pretty unnerving if you're not used to it. But it's an unbelievably important part of their herding routine. In fact, the Border Collie is one of two breeds that use their stare or eyes to move livestock around. The other breed is a Kelpie, a descendant of the Border Collie.

Border Collie Temperament
Socialisation is a key component in any Border Collie training

Unresponsiveness to the stare can lead to nipping.

The Border Collie, in general, is not the best choice for tiny children. We recommend that children from age 10 onwards be paired with this dog. They won't suffer fools gladly, although they're not known for being aggressive.

The Border Collie can be a bit wary of strangers. However, early socialisation can ease their uneasiness, and they will follow your suit quickly if they trust you. Their temperament is, in general friendly, people-orientated and openhearted.

The Border Collie has a double coat that requires regular grooming. Although their coat can come in different structures, like smooth and rough, all coats need a grooming regimen.

4 times a week should be something you should aim for. On the other hand, if you're very houseproud, another breed might be a better choice for you.

If you feel you have the time, dedication and perseverance to care for a Border Collie, you are in for a special and unique relationship. This dog will listen to your every word, always ready for adventures and new tasks. Due to the close bond the Border Collie forms with their owner, they will feel when you're upset or when you're excited. That dog doesn't only have brains. They're susceptible to your feelings, body language and facial expressions. But, due to working so closely with humans, their empathy towards their owners is second to none.

Border Collies are Velcro dogs and the happiest with you by their side. They will keep you on your toes and surprise you daily with their speed and positive life outlook.

Let's now have a look at some common Border Collie questions.

Why are Border Collies so smart?

As discussed in their history, Border Collies were selectively bred for their brains and instincts rather than appearances. This dog was seen as a classic farm dog and had to have the ability to perform as such. Especially working lineages are not bred for looks. Their brain, stamina and herding instinct are their most important asset, making them exceptional in their jobs.

But these dogs also possess a great deal of emotional intelligence, able to read humans very well. They're smart due to selective breeding and eager to solve problems and please their owner.

Border Collie vs Australian Shepherd

Although both breeds are similar in looks and can be easily confused as puppies, there are some significant differences. Border Collies originated in Northumbria, on the Border of Scotland and England. The Australian Shepherd is an American breed, although their ancestors lived presumably in Spain.

However, both species were bred for the same purpose, so their temperament can be pretty similar: Intelligent, affectionate, and highly energetic.

The Border Collie is also the "Einstein" of the dog breeds, continuously winning obedience and agility competitions. Although the Aussie Shepherd possesses an over-average intelligence, it's not matching a Border Collie.

Significant differences are observed in the coat structure. The Border Collie comes in rough and smooth coat varieties, while the outer coat can be wavy or straight. The Aussie Shepherd can have moderate featherings but will have a less harsh and less dense coat than the Border Collie.

The ears are also less erect on the Aussie Shepherd than on the Border Collie. Some owners claim that the Border Collie is more aloof with strangers. In the end, dogs, however, are individuals.

Can Border Collies be left alone?

That depends. Leaving Border Collie puppies alone for a short period can be beneficial!

They can learn to build confidence and understand that you will always come back. The Border Collie is a typical Velcro dog. They love sticking to you. Leaving them for 1-2 hours a day can be good, so they can learn to be alone. We don't recommend leaving your Border Collie alone longer, and not all of a sudden. Gradually increase the time you're away.

They do certainly need human interactions and a job to do. Unfortunately, a bored Border Collie will find a job for themselves relatively quickly, and we can't promise it won't be your skirting board. If you're away from home on a regular basis for longer than 3 hours, this dog is the wrong choice.

Border Collie Temperament
The Border Collie is a wonderful dog to own

Border Collie Temperament in a nutshell

  • People-orientated, loyal and loving

  • Early socialisation is crucial when owning a Border Collie

  • Requires an owner who is at least open to learning about obedience and agility competitions

  • Not great on their own

  • High energy and require plus 3 hrs exercise a day, mentally and physically

Potential health issues in the Border Collie breed

The Border Collie can live to a ripe age. Their average lifespan is about 14-16 years. The oldest Border Collie to live in the UK was Bramble: She had 25 years on this beautiful earth.

Border Collies are considered a healthy breed. However, there are certain health conditions that a prospective owner should be aware of. It is a good idea to budget for potential vet bills and the time required to care for your Border Collie if they develop a particular condition.

That said, not all Border Collies will experience the below hereditary diseases. It's essential to be aware of them to spot problems early on so you can follow up with immediate treatment.

The below list does not replace a vet visit. In general, always look for a vet, if your dog displays any sort of symptoms and internet research doesn't replace a vet visit.

Hip Dysplasia/Elbow Dysplasia: This is an inherited skeletal condition but can be exacerbated by fast growth and obesity and can end in painful arthritis.

Collie Eye Anomaly: Due to this anomaly, less oxygen is supplied to the retina, and this can lead to blindness

Osteochondritis Dissecans: another painful joint condition

Progressive Retinal Atrophy: Prevalent eye disease in Border Collies. This can lead to clouding and blindness

Epilepsy: Can be inherited but also appear for other reasons

MDR1-related drug sensitivity: Carriers of the gene can react allergically to certain drugs. A DNA test can quickly establish if your Border Collie is a carrier. Herding dogs often are.

Border Collie fun fact